Nicole’s Stories #2: real lessons from years of calls with home service pros. Missed #1? Read Why Your Leads Are Garbage (and It’s Not Always the Lead Provider’s Fault).
I was working down a list of home service businesses, looking at their online profiles. I wasn’t selling anything. I was just reaching out and building relationships.
Then I got to an HVAC company with a “Book online” button on its Google Business Profile. So I clicked it, the way a homeowner would.
What a homeowner saw
The button didn’t open a booking page for that company. It opened a small window asking me to pick between two software companies. Neither one had the HVAC company’s name on it.
I work in this industry, so I knew what those names meant. A homeowner with a broken AC doesn’t. They’d assume the button was broken and call the next company on the list.
If you’re curious enough to click one anyway, it gets worse. You land in a 5–7 step form that asks you to diagnose your own problem. Heating or cooling? Which part? Pick from a list of terms most people have never heard. There’s no box to just describe what’s wrong.
Most people won’t finish that. The few who do have probably called someone else halfway through.
So I called him
He answered. I introduced myself and asked if he had a minute.
“I’m not interested.”
“That’s fine, I’m not selling anything.”
“Have a nice day.” Click.
I called right back and told him I thought the booking button on his Google profile was broken. He hung up before I finished the sentence.
I know, three calls is a lot. But I’d seen what his customers were seeing, and I couldn’t unsee it. So I called a third time, got voicemail, and left a calm message: I get it, you get a million sales calls. This isn’t one. Your Google booking button points customers in two directions, and nobody knows what either one is. I can help you fix it. Then I followed up with an email.
The next week I called again. This time he remembered the email. And he said something that surprised me: he already knew about the problem. It had been a headache for a long time.
The part he couldn’t fix
He had bought an existing business. The previous owner had connected booking software to the Google profile. He had never used that software, and he couldn’t get the old provider to take the button down.
So every day, his Google profile, the first thing many customers see, was quietly sending people away.
We got on a call for about an hour. I walked him through it and helped him get the old booking link removed. It got fixed.
The lesson: you never see your business the way your customers do
He wasn’t careless. He was busy running jobs, and from his side, everything looked fine. His customers saw something completely different. They never told him. They just called someone else.
That’s true for almost every owner we talk to. You see your business from the inside. Your customers see it from a Google search on their phone. And what trips them up is rarely one big failure. It’s small things that don’t match:
- Business hours that are different on Google and on your website
- An old phone number still listed somewhere
- A booking button that goes nowhere, or to the wrong place
- Extra or duplicate Google listings you didn’t create
- A service area that doesn’t match where you actually work
Each one makes Google less sure about your business. And each one gives a customer a reason to call the next company.
Your 5-minute self-check
The fix is simple: look at your business from the outside. Grab your phone, search for your business like a customer would, and check:
- Name, phone and address. Do they match exactly on Google, your website and every directory?
- Hours. Are they the same everywhere, including holiday hours?
- Every button. Tap “Call,” “Website” and “Book online.” Does each one go where it should?
- Duplicate listings. Search your business name and phone number. Do any listings show up that you don’t recognize?
- Service area and categories. Do they match the work you actually want?
If something’s off, fix it this week. It’s some of the cheapest lead generation you’ll ever do.
Want a second set of eyes?
Most owners are too busy running jobs to see their business from the outside. That’s normal, and it’s exactly what we do. We’ll take an outside look at your Google Business Profile and website. Within a few days you’ll get what we found and an initial quote, and we do the fixes ourselves.