“My leads are garbage.” If you own a home service business, you’ve probably said it. We hear it on almost every call.
The phone number doesn’t work. The homeowner swears they never asked for a quote. Someone wants a free roof through a government grant program that doesn’t exist. You paid for every one of those.
Some leads really are bad, and you should push back on those. But in our experience, a lot of “bad leads” are good leads that got a slow call, one attempt, and no follow-up. Here’s how to tell the difference, and what to change this week.
First, separate bad leads from missed chances
A truly bad lead is one you could never have booked:
- The phone number is disconnected or wrong.
- The person says they never submitted a request.
- They want something that doesn’t exist, like a free bathroom remodel or a grant-funded roof.
- They were browsing, clicked something, and had no idea they’d asked for a quote.
Don’t count these in your numbers, and if you paid for them, ask the lead provider for a credit. Angi and Google Local Services Ads both let you request a credit for invalid leads, usually within a set window, and other platforms have their own rules. Learn your platform’s process and use it every time.
Everything else is a real person who raised their hand for help at their home. Whether that becomes a job depends mostly on what happens in the next few minutes.
Owners almost never tell us their process is the problem. Once we dig in, it’s usually an even split between the lead source and what happens after the lead arrives. Sometimes the platform settings are wrong, with job types you don’t do or a service area that’s too wide. Just as often, an owner couldn’t reach the first three leads, decided they were all bad, and stopped calling. When we called the fourth one, they answered.
What a “garbage lead” looked like on one call
A water damage restoration owner told Nicole his leads were garbage. He couldn’t get anyone on the phone. One lead had come in that same day. He’d called, and when he finally got through, the homeowner hung up on him. Had he texted? No. “I’m not a salesperson,” he said. “My job is to serve the customer.”
So Nicole called the homeowner herself. He answered, and she could hear water in the background. His basement was flooding, he was on hold with his insurance company, and he was trying to soak it up with towels. He hadn’t hung up because he wasn’t interested. He hung up because he was overwhelmed.
Nicole didn’t pitch. She asked whether the floor was carpet or hard surface, helped him find the shutoff valve and talked him through turning off the water. Then she explained that towels wouldn’t be enough, the water needed to be extracted, and the company could help with the insurance claim too. He booked an appointment for the next morning.
Same lead, same day. The only difference was a few minutes of being helpful instead of transactional. Homeowners are busy, stressed and usually talking to more than one company. Following up isn’t chasing. It’s the job, and it’s how you earn a customer who comes back and sends you referrals.
Five fixes to make this week
1. Call immediately. Not “pretty quick.”
Almost every owner tells us they call every lead right away. When we look closer, “right away” usually means somewhere between 15 minutes and 3 hours, after they finish the job they were on. By then the homeowner has filled out two more requests. Very few owners truly call the moment a lead lands, and those are the ones who book.
2. Call twice in a row, then text.
If they don’t pick up, hang up and call again right away. People ignore one unknown number, but a second call in a row tells them it isn’t spam. Leave a voicemail on the second call. Then send a text, because many homeowners would rather text than answer the phone. If the lead came through a platform like Angi or Thumbtack, send a message inside the platform too.
3. Lead with help, not with the lead source.
Don’t open with “You submitted a request through Angi?” Many homeowners don’t remember where they ended up. They started on Google, Facebook or ChatGPT and filled out a form somewhere. Open as a resource: “Hi, this is Mike with ABC Heating. I saw you’re having trouble with your AC. Tell me what’s going on.” Homeowners shop around no matter what the platform promises, so the first helpful voice usually wins.
4. Follow up on a schedule, not on memory.
One or two calls is what most owners make. Set a simple cadence and stick to it: calls, texts and emails spread over the first week, so no lead goes quiet just because you got busy. An automatic text or email when the lead arrives buys you time while you finish the job you’re on.
5. Call even when it’s not your job.
Got a basement lead and you only do roofs? Call anyway. That homeowner was told your company would reach out. Confirm what they need, refer them to someone good, and let them know you’re there when they need a roof. Ignoring them looks bad. Being human is how you get the next call.
Know your numbers before you blame the source
What a lead costs and what a job is worth varies by trade, by market and by the size of your team. A shop with a call center and 15 trucks will book a higher share than a one-truck owner, and that’s fine. What matters is a handful of ratios, counted only on real leads (the bad ones above are left out):
| Measure | What it means | Where you want to be |
|---|---|---|
| Contact rate | Leads you actually reach | 60–70% or better |
| Booking rate | Leads that turn into an appointment | At least 50%, ideally 60–70% |
| Close rate | Leads that become a paid job | Around 30% (3 in 10) |
If you’re closing 1 job out of every 10 leads, the lead source may not be the problem. Track these for one month: how many leads came in, how many you reached, how many booked, and how many closed. The weak spot usually shows up fast.
Next in Nicole’s Stories: He Hung Up on Me Twice. His Google Booking Button Was Sending Customers Away.
Not sure where your leads are slipping?
Most owners we talk to have been promised that the next lead package or agency will fix everything. Before you spend another dollar on leads, find out where the ones you already pay for are going.
Our free Funnel Review looks at how your leads come in, how fast they’re reached, and where they drop off. You’ll walk away knowing whether you have a lead problem or a follow-up problem, and what to fix first. If you’re not ready for more leads yet, we’ll tell you.